July 28, 2010
Green Gerry - “Beth’s Goodbye”

According to the handy-dandy stats-tracking features linked up to this site, not many people were interested in my mix tape post from Monday about how musical spaces shift and blend as atmosphere and fidelity gain prominence (it’s okay, I still love you). I’m glad, though, for a chance to revisit some of those ideas while talking about this song. Green Gerry splits his time between Valencia, CA and Athens, GA, using basic gear—GarageBand and a laptop microphone, mostly—to capture ambient sounds and work them into and against his predominantly folky songs. This is headphone music for sure (as Gerry himself reminds us), so turn those speakers off and find somewhere quiet to listen. The greatest rewards here are in very small details.
What I love about “Beth’s Goodbye” is the way it plays with the imagined sonic space between your ears. People tend to think of reverb as an effect meant for extending and burying sounds—there’s a habit among indie bands of applying it widely and liberally, which can result in some pretty interesting music, but isn’t always the most nuanced approach. All sounds have a natural reverberation based on the space in which they’re recorded (that’s why studios have engineers—people who know how to capture the right reverberations), so by allowing your microphone(s) to pick up the sound of the room and by not fiddling with the raw input too much, the sonic space of your recordings can mirror that of the place(s) they were recorded in. Green Gerry knows this, and he uses the echoing sound of rooms to craft a track that layers intimate and widescreen sounds on top of each other.
“Goodbye” begins with the chatter of people at a house party, the babbling voices bouncing off the flat walls and obscuring their words. Gerry leaves the sound raw in the right channel and adds a synthetic reverb in the left, highlighting the separation between them before introducing the scratchy, centered sound he’ll use for the bulk of the song’s acoustic folk middle. His gentle strums and mumbled “here we go” signal the arrival of the new space, a smaller room where guitar and voice speak clearly. In there, he sings his way through five simple verses as a tribute to his mother. He dwells on the comfort of having her watch over him and ponders the advice she gave him: “Boy, you may laugh, weep, scream, jump, and cry / don’t hold on to or cherish what you think you really know / not too many things stay too pure in this life.” Following that last line, distant footstep sounds blanketed in extra reverb make their way into the mix, suddenly creating a wide new space for the beatific choir that concludes the instrumental part of the song. All the while, Gerry’s guitar plucks along underneath, emphasizing again the difference between the environments.
As the gorgeous, wordless sighs fade away, “Goodbye” ends on the distant echoes of the party chatter from the beginning on the track, bringing it full circle but fundamentally changing it by kicking up the effects (i.e. widening the space). I realize that ‘to reverb or not to reverb’ might not be the most interesting topic when it comes to music (and maybe not all that fun to read about if you’re not familiar with it), but the thing to remember about Green Gerry is that it’s all in service of thoughtful songwriting and transportive, provocative delivery. This is a nice “♥ MOM” song, sure, but the experience of listening to it is also inextricably tied to its spacial character, the way it moves around your ears. A lot of artists try to hide the seams of that construction (or hide behind them), but Gerry lays it out for us, putting a good song in the middle of an ever-changing space to make it a sonic treat.





